Aliran Media Statement
The Finance Ministry's bailout of Tajudin Ramli's Naluri Bhd appears to
be another case of
"privatising the profits and socialising the losses."
The deal will see the Ministry buying Naluri Bhd's 29.09 per cent stake
Malaysia Airlines System Bhd (MAS) at more than twice the market price. In effect, Naluri will
receive a premium of 121 per cent or close to RM1 billion more than market value as the
Finance Ministry (and, by extension, Malaysian taxpayers) will be paying RM8 ringgit per
MAS share when the market price was only RM3.62 on 20 December.
The premium will relieve Naluri, saddled with RM888 million in bank borrowings,
reportedly burdened with huge personal debts, of much of their financial difficulties. Tajudin is
chairman of both MAS and Naluri.
MAS has posted four straight years of losses and is saddled with over RM9
billion in debts.
Its financial position today is much worse than it was when Naluri acquired the shares; so
there is no justification for the Finance Ministry to pay any premium over market price.
Even if there was a premium to be paid - which considering MAS' financial
ridiculous - how can the Finance Ministry justify paying a 121 per cent premium? Was there
an independent valuation carried out?
Recently Finance Daim Zainuddin announced Khazanah's pending purchase of
20 per cent of
TimeDotCom Bhd shares and added that the "price per unit share would be based on a
professional evaluation by a consultant" - an independent one, we presume. The people have
a right to know if a similar independent professional valuation was carried out to determine
the MAS share value.
The news of the Naluri-MAS deal comes together with the revelation that
Halim Saad is
deferring payment on the exercise of his put option in the Renong-UEM deal. Halim
announced that he would only be paying the RM3.2 billion for the 31 per cent stake in Renong
Bhd he is buying from United Engineers (Malaysia) Bhd (UEM) in instalments. He is now
expected to pay RM300 million in three equal tranches next year and the balance on 14 May
2002. Halim's deferred payment and the disposal of Renong assets to UEM for RM5.43
billion have triggered a selldown on Renong and in particular UEM shares.
Prime Minister Mahathir Mohamad has condemned foreign critics for suggesting
that the lack
of transparency and reforms in corporate governance was pulling down the Malaysian
stockmarket. If the government would only care to listen, it is not just foreign analysts but also
many concerned Malaysians who are critical of what are widely perceived as incestuous
deals and wheeling-and-dealing, often at the expense of minority shareholders and other
As long as mismanagement goes unpunished and favoured but troubled tycoons
easy escape routes, confidence in the Kuala Lumpur Stock Exchange and the economy in
general will not improve.
Although the authorities have introduced some minor reforms in the capital
seem to be missing the wood for the trees. Certainly, the introduction of measures such as
T+3 will help to curb unscrupulous market players. But the government should take a closer
look at why there has been much criticism and uneasiness over recent major deals.
Executive Committee Member
21 December 2000